Why drive LEDs with constant current?

(Edited from http://www.maximintegrated.com/en/app-notes/index.mvp/id/3256)

Abstract: When applying LEDs for display backlighting or other illumination applications, there are two reasons to drive them with constant current:

  1. To avoid violating the Absolute Maximum Current Rating and compromising the reliability.
  2. To obtain predictable and matched luminous intensity and chromaticity from each LED.

This white paper describes the characteristics of a range of typical LEDs and circuits which achieve the necessary constant-current drive.
The forward current vs. forward voltage of six random white LEDs (three from each of two manufacturers) is shown in Figure 1. In this case, driving these six LEDs with 3.4V, for instance, will cause their forward current to vary from 10mA to 44mA, depending upon the LED.

fig01

Figure 1. Forward Current versus Forward Voltage for six random white LEDs (three from each of the two leading manufacturers). Note that the forward current at any given voltage varies widely—10mA to 44mA at 3.4V, for instance.

 

For reliability, it is important to not violate the LEDs absolute maximum current rating. A typical value might be 30mA abs. max., but as shown in Figure 2, the maximum current is de-rated to handle increasing ambient temperature. It is common to limit the current to 20mA for use up to 50 degrees centigrade. By combining the information in Figures 1 and 2, it is obvious that driving white LEDs with constant voltage is not a reliable solution.

fig02

Figure 2. The absolute maximum forward current rating of a white LED is typically de-rated as ambient temperature increases. (Courtesy Nichia Corporation.)

 

Furthermore, it is important to note that a white LED’s luminous intensity and chromaticity (color) are tested and best controlled by driving it with constant current. This is also true for other color LEDs. A typical white LED specification can be seen in Figure 3.

fig03

Figure 3. For a typical white LED, the entire electrical specification is tested at IF =20mA. Therefore, to obtain predictable and matched luminous intensity and chromaticity (color), constant current drive is recommended. (Courtesy Nichia Corporation.)

 

Figure 4 shows four common power-supply circuits to drive white LEDs.

fig04a

fig04b

fig04c

fig04d

Figure 4. White LEDs are commonly powered in four different ways: (a) a voltage source and ballast resistors, (b) a current source and ballast resistors, (c) multiple current sources, and (d) a current source with the LEDs in a series connection.

 

Figure 5 shows the corresponding regulation accuracy when regulating our six random LEDs. In figure 5, the regulator’s output load-line characteristic is plotted on top of the LEDs’ Vf curves. Where the lines intersect is the regulation point for each LED.

fig05a

fig05b

fig05c

Figure 5. The variation in white-LED forward voltage (Vf) influences the current regulation accuracy differently depending upon the regulation scheme: (a) a voltage source and ballast resistors, (b) a current source and ballast resistors, (c) multiple current sources or a current source with the LEDs in series. The Vf curves of six random white LEDs (three from Lot A and three from Lot B) are shown. Where the regulator’s output Load-Line curve intersects the LED’s Vf curve is the regulation point.

 

The circuit of Figure 4a shows how to use a voltage regulator and ballast resistors to control the LED current. The advantages of this approach are that a great variety of voltage regulators may be applied this way and that only one terminal connects the regulator to the LEDs. The disadvantages are that the efficiency is not very good due to power lost in the ballast resistors and that LED forward current is not accurately controlled. Figure 5a shows that the current in our six random LEDs varies from 14.2 to 18.4mA, while brand A runs about 2mA brighter on average than brand B.

 

The circuit of Figure 4b regulates the total current applied to the LEDs, while ballast resistors are still used for LED-to-LED matching. The circuit capitalizes on the fact that the LEDs are better matched within one manufacturer’s lot and that most variation is from lot-to-lot or brand-to-brand. Because of this, the ballast resistors can be reduced to waste half as much power while providing similar current control as in the previous circuit. Figure 5b shows that the current in our six random LEDs varies from 15.4 to 19.6mA; however, brand A variation is even less and both brand A and brand B run at the same average current of 17.5mA/LED. The disadvantages are that there still remains significant power loss in the ballast resistors and the LED currents do not match perfectly. Nevertheless, this circuit represents a good compromise between performance and simplicity.

 

The circuit of Figure 4c regulates the individual current in each LED and requires no ballast resistors. Current regulation accuracy and matching is controlled by the accuracy of the individual current regulators. Because the current regulators are low dropout, the efficiency can be very high. Figure 5c shows that the regulated current is a constant 17.5mA for all six randomly selected white LEDs. The lack of ballast resistors saves board space, but four terminals are required between the regulator and LEDs. This type of circuit represents a high-performance solution that can readily compete with inductor-based solutions.

 

The circuit of Figure 4d is a high-efficiency inductor-based boost converter configured to regulate current. A low feedback threshold minimizes the power wasted in the current-sense resistor. Because the LEDs are arranged in series, the LED current matches perfectly under all conditions.

 

For high power LEDs (1W, 3W and higher), efficiency is more important. Driving LEDs with a constant current will assure high efficacy. Often times, it is also very important to dim LED at different intensities. PWM is the most efficient way to change the LED intensity while driving it at designed current. Some 1W & 3W LED drivers with PWM control can be found in our eBay store.

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s